Reader reponse to SB 226
HS writes:
Forced outpatient treatment is psychiatry's unique attempt to enlist patient motivation and commitment. Non-compliance is an issue in all branches of medicine but only psychiatry has been allowed to FORCE treatment on it's patients. Imagine legally requiring morbidly obese patients to comply with stomach stapling procedures to control their out of control eating which so taxes the medical system (diabetes, hypertension, worn out joints, sleep apnea, ripped pants seams.)
The hope, however, is that by forcing patients into psychiatric treatment they will "clear" and recognize the benefits of compliance with treatment. We all know forced treatment sucks, but don't many people see it as part of their growth toward understanding their illness and the utility of medication? Ultimately, doesn't it help people to avoid hurting themselves when they are really really sick?
Comments
Liz, you've done a great job of articulating this matter as the Mental Health Association. Evidence indicates that forced medication does not result in growth or happiness, however, HS mentions the idea of legally requiring morbidly obese people to have their stomach stapled. That one's unlikely but in the mandatory health insurance scheme most of the presidential candidates advocate, all US citizens may be legally required to follow their doctor's advice.
Posted by: Sally | September 28, 2007 02:57 PM