Thursday's International: More from the Taser files

A bipolar man in Canada who'd previously had amiable relationships with police officers died after a later encounter went wrong. From the Chronicle Herald:
"We were dispatched to provide assistance to a person who appeared to be mentally disturbed," testified [officer] Clement.Three officers were present and they went inside the garage. To Clement’s surprise, it was the man he’d met outside the coffee shop.
But Clement said he quickly realized something was very wrong because of the way he was talking.
"He gave me directions for where to walk and where to step because I was entering a voodoo garden," said the constable.
"It was obvious to me Kevin had lost contact with reality."
While two officers stayed with Geldart, Clement went inside the home and spoke to the parents, who told him their son has suffered from bipolar disorder since he was 18 and was having a psychotic episode.
Clement testified the parents said he had to be dealt with because he was "losing it."
Things went from bad to worse after Geldart got to the ER and became violent. Three days later, in another violent encounter, the officers shocked Geldart with 50,000 volts to subdue him, but the shocks killed him. At an inquest, his sister passed around photos of Geldart, and shared stories. From the Chronicle Herald:
She talked about the fact her brother loved Monty Python and the Rolling Stones, and how he played with Lego as a youngster and got good grades in school.But when he got to junior high, she said he began to miss classes and smoke marijuana. He didn’t apply himself in high school and developed depression and insomnia.
He was diagnosed at the age of 18 with the mental illness and would later be placed on permanent disability.
And therein begins and ends, in a sense, a sad tale. In this instance, however, I think the officers sounded very sympathetic and reluctant to use force.


Comments
At issue here is the commitment (to psychiatric care) system in Canada. As I am sure you and your readers know in the US commitment requirements vary from state to state and can range from systems which commit easily to those where psychiatric commitment is nigh impossible.
I was once at a commitment hearing where the judge insisted that the distance between the knife the patient was waving and the other people in the room was very relevant to his level of dangerousness. I have had other patients (in another state) committed for walking out of an emergency room and refusing treatment and having unsupportive families. The best solution would be a clearcut federal standard but the legal system makes that impossible.
Posted by: HS | February 22, 2007 10:48 AM
Mentally ill languish in state prisons
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-lopez22feb22,0,6772038.column?coll=la-home-headlines
Posted by: EVS | February 22, 2007 11:57 AM
I almost wish I hadn't read that because it really made me sick. I don't understand why the police used taser to such a degree it killed the man.
When I was in Paris and had a manic attack in public I was pretty aggressive. Maybe not as much as this man, but anyway, what they do there is put you in a 24 hour police holding place with doctor specifically for out-of-control people who look like they might have MI. They don't taser you. They sedate and restrain you. It wasn't comfortable, but it wasn't bad. Then they figure out whether you need to go to the mental hospital for a stay (which is free for citizens).
Tasering repeatedly? I don't see this as a safe way of restraining a MI person in an episode. It's just terrible.
Posted by: Annette | February 23, 2007 10:01 PM